Petition For Ubisoft To Cancel Assassin's Creed Shadows Hits 50K Signatures

Updated Jul 5, 2024

Followed

Summary

A petition to cancel Assassin's Creed Shadows has reached 50,000 signatures, criticizing its historical accuracy and cultural respect.
The petition accuses Ubisoft of Asian racism and calls for the game's release to be canceled until the studio shows "sincere research and respect for Japanese history and culture."
Ubisoft has yet to respond to the petition, with Assassin's Creed Shadows currently set to launch on November 15.

A new petition to cancel the first story trailer - there has been a fair amount of controversy, largely regarding the appearance of the African samurai Yasuke.

The Change.org petition by Shimizu Toru states, "the lack of historical accuracy and cultural respect has been a serious issue regarding the game Assassin’s Creed Shadows by game developer Ubisoft. The game is based on Japanese samurai and ignores the fact that samurai were a higher class of warrior class and should have been ‘gokenin’ or servants of nobles." It then goes on to say that the game is "a serious insult to Japanese culture and history," suggesting its creators' intent may be "linked to Asian racism," before calling for the game's release to be canceled until Ubisoft shows "sincere research and respect for Japanese history and culture."

The original petition was written in Japanese, and the quotes used in this article came from Google's translation to English.

The Most Replayable AC Game Yet: Assassin's Creed Shadows Developer On Its Characters & Gameplay

The producer of Assassin's Creed Shadows spoke with Screen Rant at Summer Game Fest to discuss what players can expect from the game.

Posts

Ubisoft's Statements About Historical Accuracy Seem To Be Behind The Outrage

Yasuke May Be A Historical Figure, But Many Facts About Him Are Still Unknown

From Leonardo da Vinci in Assassin's Creed 2 to Queen Victoria in Assassin's Creed Syndicate, Ubisoft has always sprinkled in historical figures across the series, but they were never playable until now. In the "Who are Naoe and Yasuke?" featurette that accompanied Assassin's Creed Shadows' story trailer on real historical figure. The footage then states that he is someone new to the land, having arrived in Japan in 1579 before developing a relationship with the powerful Oda Nobunaga, which has been documented historically.

In Assassin's Creed Shadows, Yasuke seems to be invited to Nobunaga's army and rise to the rank of samurai, becoming part of Nobunaga's inner circle, and this seems to be where he developed the more combat-heavy samurai skills shown in the gameplay footage. In real life, while it has been documented that Nobunaga was fascinated by Yasuke's appearance and did have him armed with a sword as he accompanied him, he may never have actually reached the rank of samurai, instead serving more as a kind of attendant. There have been no historical sources regarding Yasuke after his time with Nobunaga.

Naoe and Yasuke from Assassin’s Creed Shadows.

Assassin’s Creed Shadows: Release Date, Protagonists, Setting, & Story

The first trailer for Assassin’s Creed Shadows reveals its release date, dual protagonists, and the first inklings of a story. Here’s what to expect.

Posts

Naoe Being A Fictional Character Seems To Be Why She Hasn't Been Criticized

Although Her Father In The Game Is Based On A Real Shinobi

It's worth noting that the petition doesn't seem to criticize the portrayal of the shinobi - also commonly referred to as ninjas in most media - in Assassin's Creed Shadows, focusing largely on Yasuke. This could be because the game's stealth-based character, Naoe, is fictional. However, the aforementioned "Who are Naoe and Yasuke?" featurette states that she is the daughter of the real shinobi Fujibayashi Nagato, and comes from the real shinobi province of Iga.

If anything, the portrayal of the ninja in Assassin's Creed Shadows - and in general pop culture - could also be accused of being inaccurate. Shinobi were primarily spies and were very rarely assassins, often operating in disguise or undercover by using civilian clothing that would allow them to blend in with their surroundings and move discreetly. This attire would usually be fairly non-descript, matching lower-class workers with straw hats to aid in covering their faces, rather than in the black ninja uniforms shown in most media - which Naoe's hooded black assassin attire seems to stem from - but the petition doesn’t mention that, probably because it has so widely become considered the norm due to the regularity of which the group has been depicted in this fashion.

Yaoe may be completely fictional, but it's the lack of in-depth documentation surrounding Yasuke that has given Ubisoft plenty of room to play with his story. While past historical cameos may have been accepted as fun, and the series has always been largely fictional with its depictions of magical artifacts, the claims of accuracy in Assassin's Creed Shadows have clearly drawn outrage among some fans. Ubisoft has yet to respond to the petition, so Assassin's Creed Shadows is currently due to launch on November 15, with those who pre-order the Gold or Ultimate editions of the game or those who are subscribed to Ubisoft+ getting the game three days early.

Sources: Change.org, Ubisoft/YouTube