Deadwood is still considered one of the best Western television series of all time, attributed in no small part to the historical accuracy depicting the events that shaped the real frontier town of Deadwood. The show follows Sheriff Seth Bullock (Timothy Olyphant) and saloon-owner Al Swearengen (Ian McShane), two real figures in Deadwood's origin story. It was also populated by some of the Wild West's most enduring icons, like Wild Bill Hickok and Calamity Jane. Deadwood blended truth with fiction to tell an exciting narrative about the hardships and opportunities of the mining town.
Even though Deadwood was canceled after 3 seasons, there's no denying it's a well-documented and researched series that offers a glimpse into the harsh realities of life in the American West. The creators, writers, and actors took the time to be as historically accurate wherever possible while also applying creative license to embellish characters who were inspired by the sort of people who would seek their fortunes in Deadwood. Watching it feels as close to actually being a fly on the wall of Al's saloon as fans can possibly get in the Western genre.
15 The Crédit Mobilier Scandal Really Affected New Investments
A Financial Scandal Had Reaching Consequences
Deadwood takes a lot of liberties with its history, but one of the ways it is able to comment on history while telling its own story is through subtle hints. At various times in the series, there is mention by several characters of difficulties getting investors on board with their new ventures due to a financial scandal that took place out east. While there are no specifics given to what happened, the characters are referring to the Crédit Mobilier scandal.
The scandal came from several executives of Union Pacific who defrauded investors during the building of a new railroad line in the 1860s. However, while the project was only going to cost $50 million, the executives raised nearly double that amount and pocketed the excess wealth. Though a smaller impact on the overall story, it is interesting how this small bit of history was made to influence certain events of the show.
14 A Shooting In The Gem Saloon
Trixie's Character May Have Come From A Real Incident
Trixie (Paula Malcomson) is one of the standout characters in Deadwood as one of the sex workers at the Gem Saloon. While it is shown that she is intimidated by Al Swearengen in the early episodes, she is also shown to be a tough and capable woman in her own right who is not afraid to defend herself. This is clearly shown in her introductory scene in which Trixie shoots a customer who was allegedly beating her.
As it turns out, this is likely a story the show took from the real history of Deadwood and may have helped to create the character of Trixie. According to Legends of America, there was a report of a sex worker at the Gem Saloon known only as Tricksie who once shot a customer in the head. As is depicted in the show, the man did not immediately die from the wound.
13 Bullock's Public Hanging
Bullock's Insistence On Seeing Justice Done Was A Real Event
The first scene of Deadwood is a terrific introduction to this harsh Western world while also being a perfect way of establishing Seth Bullock's hardened belief in seeing justice served. As Seth and Sol Starr are preparing to head off and start their new life in Deadwood, they are overseeing a prisoner who is being held until his execution. However, when an angry mob arrives to lynch the man, Bullock will not allow mob justice to take over.
According to the book, Seth Bullock: Black Hills Lawman, this was taken from a real story attributed to Bullock in which he held a mob back at gunpoint and carried out the hanging himself. The moment becomes a defining one for Bullock and is even referenced in the Deadwood movie where Bullock nearly lets the mob kill George Hearst before choosing the protect the man and uphold the law.
12 The Peak Of The Black Hills Gold Rush Was 1876-1877
Gold Discovery In 1874 Spurred Deadwood's Rapid Growth
The narrative of Deadwood centered around Dakota's Black Hills gold rush, and the show portrayed this unique period in US history incredibly well. With Colonel Custer patrolling the Dakota territory looking for the perfect place to build a fort, the Black Hills Expedition of 1874 prompted the curious and intrepid to follow his example. Once gold was discovered in the Black Hills, opportunistic settlers came from all over the nation (and the world) to make their claims and strike it rich.
Deadwood's historically accurate gold rush even stretches to its titular town, as there is a real Deadwood in South Dakota, and just like its namesake in the TV show, it was founded during the Black Hills Gold Rush. The town of Deadwood grew out of this unexpected boom, beginning as a collection of shanties until Al Swearengen established his Gem Theater in 1876, and a merchant class emerged selling tools and mercantile to prospectors hoping to make their fortunes and settle in the town while land was still inexpensive.
11 Wild Bill Hickok Was Shot & Killed By Jack McCall While Playing Poker
Wild Bill Hickok Was Killed In 1876
Keith Carradine played Wild Bill Hickock in Deadwood, and his portrayal was one of the most accurate real-life characters on the show. Wild Bill Hickok, one of the most famous gunslingers in Wild West lore, came to Deadwood in 1876 as part of Charlie Utter's wagon train along with Calamity Jane. At that point in his life, men were anxious to make a reputation for themselves by killing such a well-known folk hero, which is just what Jack McCall did. Many Western TV shows and movies use real gunslingers, outlaws, and cowboys from the era but alter historical details.
Why Ricky Jay’s Eddie Sawyer Left HBO’s Deadwood In Season 2
Ricky Jay's Eddie Sawyer was a minor character in Deadwood season 1, but his sudden season 2 exit made it hard not to wonder what happened to him.
When it comes to Wild Bill Hickock, however, Deadwood stays true to real life, including at the moment of his death. According to the official Deadwood site devoted to the town and its history, after playing several rounds with Hickok and losing badly the previous day (Hickok even lent him money to cover his breakfast), an insulted McCall found Hickok at his preferred saloon where he was sitting uncharacteristically with his back to the door and shot him in the back of the head.
10 McCall Was Found Not Guilty In His First Trial
McCall's Questionable Defense Was Also Based On Reality
As is depicted in Deadwood, it did not take long for Jack McCall to be taken into custody for the murder of Wild Bill. An impromptu trial was quickly formed. In the series, the trial takes place at the Gem Saloon, whereas in reality, it happened at McDaniel's Theater. Despite there being several witnesses to McCall shooting Wild Bill, McCall claimed that the murder was due to the famed outlaw having killed McCall's brother years earlier.
McCall was found not guilty of the crime and quickly fled Deadwood as is shown in the series. However, the events surrounding McCall's fate after that are dramatized for the series. Bullock hunts McCall down and arrests him again for the crimes that did not happen in reality. McCall was simply arrested again in Wyoming after bragging about the murder and the court decided the "not guilty" verdict in Deadwood didn't apply to the lawful states. He was tried again, found guilty, and hanged.
9 Deadwood's Chinese Community
The Immigrants Established Their Own Culture While Also ing The Community
One of the most interesting aspects of the town of Deadwood depicted in the series is the Chinese community. While Mister Wu (Keone Young) is the main character who represents this community, they are shown to be a thriving part of the town, involved in various business enterprises, including Wu's dealings with Al Swearengen.
In reality, there was a large Chinese community in Deadwood and the town served as one of the few that would welcome Asian immigrants at this time. There was a large anti-Chinese immigration sentiment in the United States during the era, but it was reported that the Chinese immigrants in Deadwood were generally welcomed. They had set up a section of town to maintain their own culture with one another, but they were also known to be involved with the overall community.
8 There Was A Smallpox Outbreak In 1876
Calamity Jane Helped Deadwood
Outlaws and violence weren't the deadliest things facing citizens of small towns like Deadwood during the late 19th century. As Deadwood showed, the disease was perhaps the biggest risk those living in frontier towns faced. Deadwood showed the impact of smallpox incredibly well, but it's more historically accurate than first appeared, as the 1876 epidemic in the town actually happened. What's more, the show's inclusion of Wild West legend Calamity Jane was also true to real life.
When a smallpox outbreak ripped through Deadwood, quarantine tents were set up to care for the sick known as pest houses, and at great risk to herself, Calamity Jane helped care for the ill that were brought to them during the epidemic. The Deadwood site claims that smallpox claimed 300 lives, or what amounted to a third of the town's population in 1876.
While it had a devastating effect on the local economy as shops folded up within days of inhabitants contracting the disease, the town was also able to rebuild and became known for the collective spirit of its citizens who persevered in spite of great losses.
Calamity Jane also played Susan in The Sessions (2012)
7 The Real Metz Family Were Killed In 1876
One Of The Most Horrific Incidents in Deadwood
One of the most horrific incidents in Deadwood was, shockingly, historically accurate — the Metz family massacre. The Metz family, a group of Dutch settlers traveling through Deadwood to Minnesota, were real individuals (even if they're not as well known as the likes of Calamity Jane or Wild Bill Hickock). Deadwood changed a lot about Al Swearengen but not his brutality, and when the Metz encampment was attacked by Swearengen's men, they made it resemble the handiwork of the Siouxe.
The real Metz family massacre happened in 1876, and at the time was blamed on the famed Native American warrior Crazy Horse, the Lakota war leader who spearheaded many battles against the encroaching United States. According to the Spearfish Area Historical Society, there were no survivors in the Metz massacre, whereas, in Deadwood, one little girl named Sofia (Bree Seanna Wall) is taken in by The Widow. Sofia is closely watched by Swearengen, who hopes that when she eventually starts to speak, she won't be able to identify any of his men.
6 South Dakota Became A State In 1889
Statehood Transformed Deadwood
A decade separates the end of the series and the Deadwood movie, and the narrative reflects the age of time for all the characters. Just as with the main show, the Deadwood movie takes pains to ensure historical accuracy, and one of the key events it displays is South Dakota's ascension to statehood and the impact it has on the titular settlement. The Deadwood movie takes place in 1889 and is historically accurate when it comes to the celebrations, as this was the same year that South Dakota became an official state.
The celebrations are the key reason many characters have come back together. What's more, in the time that the Dakota territory officially became a state, the town of Deadwood grew from a collection of shacks into a real cosmopolitan space with bustling streets and its own train station. After South Dakota became a state and Deadwood benefited from being able to transport resources like lumber and ore by rail, it flourished into a prosperous town that barely resembled what it had been just a decade before.
