Dobby’s death in Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone marked the beginning of J.K Rowling’s stories set in the Wizarding World, which culminated in 2007 with the publishing of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. All seven books were adapted into movies from 2001 to 2011, with the final book being split into a two-part movie.

Like any other book series adapted to the big screen, the Harry Potter books, and a character whose death was wasted in the movies.

Related: Harry Potter: The Marauders & How They Got Their Names Explained

Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets, was ignored in the movies and ended up making his death less significant.

Dobbys death in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows

Dobby appeared only twice in the movie saga: in Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and Bellatrix Lestrange threw her knife at Harry and it disapparated with them, fatally wounding Dobby, who died in Harry’s arms at Shell Cottage.

In the movies, Dobby was nothing more than the former Malfoy’s house-elf who warned Harry about the Chamber of Secrets and later appeared to save them from the Death Eaters. Dobby did so much more than that in the books, which was what made his death so heartbreaking. Since the movies ignored most of his story, his death was wasted and simply used as a bridge between the two Deathly Hallows movies, turning it into a shallow plot device and taking away all its meaning.

There were many deaths in the Harry Potter series, but Dobby’s was among the most significant ones because of everything he did, not only for Harry and his friends, but for others as well. By ignoring all his actions between his first and last appearances, the movies did a disservice to a great character and denied viewers one of the best friendships in the book series.

Next: Why J.K Rowling Keeps Changing Harry Potter Canon