Summary

• Liane Moriarty's TV adaptations captivate audiences with star-studded casts and intricate plots that delve into complex themes.
• Apples Never Fall struggles to differentiate itself, relying on worn-out tropes compared to Moriarty's previous standouts.
• While Nine Perfect Strangers tries to weave multiple narratives, it doesn't capture the emotional depth of Big Little Lies.

Liane Moriarty has become a household name thanks to her intriguing novels being adapted into captivating TV series. From the star-studded HBO hit Big Little Lies to the mysterious characters of Nine Perfect Strangers, her works have drawn audiences in. The latest addition to the world of Liane Moriarty, Apples Never Fall, adds another layer to the mix, leaving viewers wondering which adaptation stands out as the best. Moriarty's novels have gained popularity for their clever storytelling, engaging characters, and thought-provoking themes. Her ability to craft narratives that blend mystery, humor, and heartfelt moments has made her a beloved author.

As her works continue to be adapted for the small screen, attracting top-tier talent and garnering critical acclaim, it becomes increasingly clear that Moriarty's stories resonate with audiences on a deep level. Each adaptation brings its own unique flavor to the table, showcasing the versatility and depth of Moriarty's writing. With the release of Apples Never Fall, the question arises: which of these three adaptations truly captures the essence of Moriarty's storytelling and stands out as the most compelling visual representation of her work?

3 Apples Never Fall (2024)

Available to stream on Peacock

Apples Never Fall is the latest television adaptation of Liane Moriarty's novel, but it struggles to stand out in the crowded landscape of other characters from the author’s previous adaptations, all centered around affluent families and their troubles. While Annette Bening delivers a nuanced and captivating performance as Joy Delaney, a retired tennis academy owner grappling with feelings of loneliness and a lack of purpose, the series often relies on well-worn plotlines and tropes that have become all too familiar in recent years. It is lacking the freshness, originality, and depth that made the other shows a standout success.

The show's focus on the family's misbehavior and dysfunction, while occasionally elevated by Bening's powerful portrayal of Joy's inner turmoil and quiet desperation, ultimately fails to offer a truly unique or compelling perspective on its central themes. Joy's willingness to welcome a mysterious stranger into her home, despite knowing little about her background or motivations, hints at the character's profound sense of isolation and yearning for connection. Despite this, the series struggles to fully explore this and other complex themes with the depth and nuance they deserve.

The acting of the ing cast is solid, but not exceptional. Additionally, the overall story, while engaging at times, fails to break new ground or offer any astounding twists or revelations. Though Apples Never Fall makes some changes to the book, it ultimately fails to establish itself as a must-watch entry in an increasingly crowded genre, relying too heavily on familiar plot devices and lacking the innovative storytelling and fresh perspectives that could have set it apart from its predecessors.

2 Nine Perfect Strangers (2021)

Available to stream on Hulu

Nine Perfect Strangers manages to carve out its own niche in the realm of star-studded, character-driven dramas. The series follows nine individuals as they embark on a transformative journey at Tranquillum House, a wellness retreat led by the enigmatic Masha, portrayed by Nicole Kidman. With her ethereal appearance, piercing gaze, and inconsistent Russian accent, Masha embodies the archetypal cult leader, captivating her guests and viewers alike. The show's hook lies in its intriguing premise, as guests are served personalized smoothies and presented with non-disclosure agreements upon arrival, hinting at the unconventional and potentially dangerous nature of the retreat.

The colorful array of activities, ranging from potato sack races to grave digging, adds to the show's allure. The dialogue is sharp and provocative, with comedic performers like Melissa McCarthy showcasing their wit while also focusing on substantial backstories. Kidman's portrayal of Masha is undeniably the series' selling point, as her character's mysterious past and questionable motives keep both the guests and the audience guessing. With Nine Perfect Strangers season 2 on the way, the show's intrigue and the cast's collective energy make for an entertaining watch, but it falls short of the emotional depth achieved by Big Little Lies.

Nine Perfect Strangers attempts to juggle multiple character arcs, resulting in a relay race of feelings that doesn't allow for a fully satisfying exploration of any single narrative thread. Consequently, the series feels overstuffed at times, lacking the focus and impact that had come to be expected. While the acting is commendable and the story engaging, the adaptation doesn't quite reach the same heights as its source material. It may not sur its predecessors, but it certainly offers a unique and captivating viewing experience that sets it apart from the less successful adaptations in the Moriarty television universe.

1 Big Little Lies (2017)

Available to stream on Max

HBO’s Big Little Lies, Liane Moriarty's best-selling novel, stands out as the crown jewel among the author's television adaptations. The series boasts an all-star cast, including Reese Witherspoon, Nicole Kidman, Shailene Woodley, Zoë Kravitz, and Laura Dern, who bring to life the complex and captivating characters at the heart of the story. The show's first season is a masterful translation of the source material, capturing the essence of the novel while also elevating it through the medium of television. The intricate plot, which revolves around a murder investigation that slowly unravels the lives of five women, is expertly crafted.

The performances of the lead actresses are nothing short of extraordinary, with each one bringing depth and authenticity to their roles. Their chemistry is palpable, and their interactions feel genuine. The series also tackles important themes, such as domestic abuse, parenting, and female friendships, adding layers of meaning to the already compelling narrative. The show's success is evident in the numerous accolades it has received, including eight Primetime Emmy Awards for its first season. The second season, which features the addition of Meryl Streep, further demonstrates the series' ability to attract top talent and maintain its high quality.

Although the second season may not have garnered the same universal acclaim as the first, it still earned critical praise and Emmy nominations for both Streep and Dern's performances. Big Little Lies sets itself apart from other Moriarty adaptations by its ability to fully realize the potential of its source material, creating a visually stunning and emotionally resonant viewing experience. In comparison to the other adaptations, Big Little Lies stands as a shining example of how to successfully translate a beloved novel to the screen, honoring the original work while also creating something truly exceptional in its own right.