The poor box office return of Disney/Pixar’s strongest depictions of LGBTQ+ relationships with Commander Alisha Hawthorn and her wife, its poor numbers—and the unsurprising backlash to that aspect—could leave future Pixar films with queer storylines in flux.
The lesbian relationship in Lightyear isn’t actually the first depiction in the Toy Story series. There’s a split second in The Incredibles 2). So, there wasn’t yet a financial deterrent for including further, or even expanded, depictions of LGBTQ+ characters.
Still, Lightyear already had a tough job ahead of it. As with any beloved franchise, whether audiences will accept a new entry is a toss of a coin, and the Toy Story series is the flagship for Pixar Studios. Taking such a sideways approach for a film about a major character—wherein this is the in-universe film that made Tim Allen’s Buzz a toy in the first place—was truly a risk that didn’t pay off. Studios often look for a scapegoat after a commercial failure, and rather than reevaluating the decision to make this film in the first place, it’s possible Pixar will decide that portraying Alisha and her wife was the wrong call.
Disney and its associated studios are no strangers to displaying this kind of overreaction. With the extreme fan backlash to new character Rose Tico in Beauty and the Beast remake to Disney employees revealing in an open letter that many queer characters and storylines were cut from films, the studio is regularly disappointing its LGBTQ+ viewers.
With this in mind, it’s unclear how Disney is going to treat future films. Even as the studio was working on Lightyear, it backed away from stronger LGBTQ+ stories. Notably, when it acquired and subsequently shuttered Blue Sky Studios, Disney cut the cord on the animated adaptation of Nimona, a graphic novel with several queer themes. Still, it’s moving forward with other representations. At the Annecy International Animation Film Festival, a sneak peek for Walt Disney Animated Studios’ film Strange World depicted main character Ethan flirting with Diazo, another boy. This has led audiences to believe that Ethan will be openly gay. However, with little known about the film’s plot or how prominent Diazo’s character is, there’s no guarantee that Disney is finally committing to true representation. If it’s easy to remove without losing the film’s integrity, it’s possible that the Lightyear failure will tempt Disney to leave that plot on the cutting room floor.
The reaction to Lightyear—as well as past Pixar films like Onward—certainly isn’t a motivator for Disney Studios’ approach to LGBTQ+ representation in its films. But it shouldn’t be enough to condemn future depictions. If the studio can introduce prominent queer characters in strong stories, it’s more likely to see box office numbers to justify a legitimate commitment to this community of viewers.
