Summary
- Apple TV+'s Presumed Innocent boasts a talented cast that shines in this character-driven crime drama series.
- The slow-burn thriller is packed with twists and turns, keeping viewers hooked with well-written character beats.
- The extended runtime of the television format allows for a deeper dive into each character's psyche in this murder mystery drama.
Given how Apple TV+'s Presumed Innocent is a character-driven crime drama, it is not surprising that it includes a talented roster of actors. Based on the 1990 film of the same name (which was adapted from a novel by Scott Turow), Presumed Innocent is a slow-burn thriller, but packs enough twists and turns to keep viewers hooked throughout its runtime. Unlike the original movie, which mostly earned positive reviews from critics, Apple TV+'s Presumed Innocent also benefits from its television format because it allows the original story to have an extended runtime and delve deeper into each character's psyche.
Owing to this, apart from snagging a viewer's attention with its surprising twists, the Apple TV+ show also keeps audiences entertained with its well-written character beats. What further heightens its murder mystery drama is the brilliant performance of nearly every actor. Owing to this, after watching Presumed Innocent on Apple TV+, it can be hard not to wonder who plays whom in the series.
Actor |
Character in Presumed Innocent |
Jake Gyllenhaal |
Rusty Sabich |
Ruth Negga |
Barbara Sabich |
Bill Camp |
Raymond Horgan |
Renate Reinsve |
Carolyn Polhemus |
Peter Sarsgaard |
Tommy Molto |
Elizabeth Marvel |
Lorraine Horgan |
Chase Infiniti |
Chase Sabich |
Kingston Rumi Southwick |
Kyle Sabich |
Lily Rabe |
Dr. Liz Rush |
Noma Dumezweni |
Judge Lyttle |
Jake Gyllenhaal as Rusty Sabich
Date Of Birth: December 19, 1980
- Active Since: 1991
Actor: Son of director Stephen Gyllenhaal and screenwriter Naomi Foner, Jake Gyllenhaal started acting at a very young age by making his acting debut in City Slickers. His first lead role came in 1999's October Sky, which instantly got him immense acclaim and helped him land more mainstream parts. Since then, Jake Gyllenhaal has starred in multiple acclaimed dramas and blockbuster franchise films, making him one of the most accomplished actors of modern times. In Presumed Innocent, Gyllenhaal plays his first major television role.
Notable Movies & Shows:
Movie |
Role |
Donnie Darko |
Donnie Darko |
Brokeback Mountain |
Jack Twist |
Prisoners |
Detective Loki |
Spider-Man: Far From Home |
Mysterio |
Nightcrawler |
Louis Bloom |
Character: Jake Gyllenhaal plays the main character, Rusty Sabich, in Presumed Innocent, who is initially portrayed as an accomplished prosecutor. However, his life turns upside down when he becomes the prime suspect in the murder of one of his former colleagues. The more the details surrounding the murder begin to surface, the more Sabich finds himself regretting his past choices and decisions.
Ruth Negga as Barbara Sabich
Date Of Birth: May 4, 1981
- Active Since: 2004
Actor: Born in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, Ruth Negga made her acting debut with the Irish film Capital Letters in 2004. In the year that followed, she appeared in Brian W. Cook's Colour Me Kubrick alongside John Malkovich. The actress also has a long history of working in television shows like Criminal Justice, Personal Affairs, and Love Is the Drug.
Notable Movies & Shows:
Movie |
Role |
Breakfast on Pluto |
Charlie |
Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. |
Raina |
ing |
Clare |
Preacher |
Tulip O'Hare |
Character: Ruth Negga's character, Barbara Sabich, is Rusty's wife in Presumed Innocent. She, too, indirectly gets embroiled in her husband's legal battle and faces the consequences of his past actions. However, despite this, she tries her best to forgive him for their children's sake.

18 Best Jake Gyllenhaal Movies, Ranked
From Donnie Darko to Ambulance, Jake Gyllenhaal delivers - and the best Jake Gyllenhaal movies are some of the best character acting in cinema.
Bill Camp as Raymond Horgan
Date Of Birth: October 13, 1961
- Active Since: 1989
Actor: Born and raised in Massachusetts, Bill Camp started his acting career with myriad roles in theater, only to later move to film and television. The veteran star has more than 70 acting credits under his belt and has appeared in several acclaimed movies, like Lincoln, 12 Years A Slave, and Joker. Even in television, he has played memorable parts in Queen's Gambit, American Rust, The Night Of, and Broadwalk Empire.
Notable Movies & Shows:
Movie |
Role |
Birdman |
Crazy Man |
12 Years a Slave |
Radburn |
The Killing of a Sacred Deer |
Matthew Willaims |
The Queen's Gambit |
Mr. Shaibel |
Character: In Presumed Innocent, Bill Camp's character, Raymond, initially encourages Rusty to take Renate's case, unaware of their past relationship. Since Rusty does not tell him about it, Bill is initially mad at him for tainting his reputation. However, he later forgives Raymond and becomes his defendant in court.
Renate Reinsve as Carolyn Polhemus
Date Of Birth: November 24, 1987
- Active Since: 2011
Actor: After starting her acting career in 2011, Renate Reinsve first received appreciation for her talent when she earned the Hedda Award for playing a role in the Swiss play Besøk av gammel dame. Later, although Reinsve was on the verge of giving up acting for carpentry, she landed her breakthrough role in The Worst Person in the World, which helped her garner more mainstream attention. Since then, she has starred in several movies and also won many accolades, like the BAFTA, for her brilliant performances.
Notable Movies & Shows:
Movie |
Role |
The Worst Person in the World |
Julie |
A Different Man |
Ingrid |
Welcome to Norway |
Line |
Best før |
Anemone |
Character: Renate Reinsve's Carolyn is Rusty's former co-worker who is found murdered in her apartment. Investigation into the case reveals that she and Rusty had an affair long before her death, which makes Rusty a prime suspect. Although Carolyn dies in Presumed Innocent's first episode, the series features her through flashbacks.

Every Jake Gyllenhaal Movie & TV Show
Jake Gyllenhaal has found great success with his Road House remake. Here's what the actor has coming next, including a promising 2024 miniseries.
Presumed Innocent ing Cast & Characters
Peter Sarsgaard as Tommy Molto: Best known for his roles in The Batman, Jarhead, Shattered Glass, and Blue Jasmine, Peter Sarsgaard plays Tommy Molto in Presumed Innocent, who is the prosecutor in the central case.
Elizabeth Marvel as Lorraine Horgan: Bill Camp's real wife, Elizabeth Marvel, plays his character's wife, Lorraine, in Presumed Innocent.
Chase Infiniti as Jaden Sabich: Chase Infiniti portrays Rusty's daughter, Jaden, in the Apple TV+ series.
Kingston Rumi Southwick as Kyle Sabich: Kingston Rumi Southwick, of the 9 Full Moons fame, portrays Rusty's son, Kyle.
Lily Rabe as Dr. Liz Rush: Lily Rabe, who recently appeared in the HBO crime drama Love & Death, stars as Rusty and Ruth's marriage counselor, Dr. Liz, on the show.
Noma Dumezweni as Judge Lyttle: Noma Dumezweni, known for her roles in The Boy Who Harnessed the Wind, The Little Mermaid, and Dirty Pretty Things, appears as the judge in the central case in Presumed Innocent.

Presumed Innocent
- Release Date
- 2024 - 2024-00-00
An eight-episode limited series based on the New York Times bestselling novel of the same name by Scott Turow. Starring Gyllenhaal in the lead role of chief deputy prosecutor Rusty Sabich, the series takes viewers on a gripping journey through the horrific murder that upends the Chicago Prosecuting Attorney’s office when one of its own is suspected of the crime. The series explores obsession, sex, politics, and the power and limits of love, as the accused fights to hold his family and marriage together.