The short Jeffrey Dean Morgan Shameless appearance has confused both viewers of the show and followers of the actor, and it seems confusing how the Walking Dead star's character only appeared for a single episode. Jeffrey Dean Morgan is best known for playing Negan on The Walking Dead, as well as The Comedian in Zack Snyder's Watchmen, and broke many hearts on Grey's Anatomy as Denny Duquette, and played John Winchester on Supernatural. However, he also briefly appeared on Showtime's dramedy Shameless in 2011.
Shameless debuted in 2011, and was a remake of a UK show with a Chicago setting. In 2014, Jeffrey Dean Morgan appeared during the season 4 finale as Charlie Peters, owner of the Golden House Restaurant. However, after this brief appearance, Charlie in Shameless never returns. It's odd, considering the series set up the character to be a mainstay, but he was then replaced by Dermot Mulroney (My Best Friend's Wedding). Because of this, viewers still question why the Jeffrey Dean Morgan Shameless character disappeared after only one episode.
Shameless: 11 Character Exits That Saved The Show (& 11 That Hurt It)
Many iconic characters on Shameless have come and gone. Some of their departures have bettered the show, but others have actually harmed it.
Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Shameless Character Explained
Charlie Appeared Only Once, In The Season 4 Finale
Jeffrey Dean Morgan played Charlie Peters in Shameless, who appeared in season 4, episode 12, "Lazarus". Charlie was introduced in Shameless as part of Fiona Gallaghers's season 4 narrative arc, with the intention having been for him to be a recurring character in season 5 onwards. He's first seen when Fiona is given a job at the Golden House Restaurant after being brought there by her parole officer Gail, with Charlie agreeing to give Fiona a chance, though warning if she shows up drunk or high she'll be fired and reported.
Charlie and Fiona attend a Recovery meeting together, setting Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Shameless character up as a positive influence for Fiona and a possibly integral part of her storyline in the next season.
Later in the episode, Charlie and Fiona attend a Recovery meeting together, setting Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Shameless character up as a positive influence for Fiona and a possibly integral part of her storyline in the next season. However, in Shameless season 5, Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Charlie was nowhere to be seen, and the restaurant is renamed Patsy's Pies. Of course, it makes no sense to bring in Morgan for such a small part unless it was supposed to be bigger, and Charlie was meant to play a much larger role in the fifth season.
Shameless: All Of Fiona's Odd Jobs, Ranked
Fiona Gallagher held down many jobs over the course of Shameless, but what were her worst and best employment opportunities throughout the show?
Jeffrey Dean Morgan Left Shameless Due To A Scheduling Conflict
Filming For Texas Rising Clashed With His Work On Shameless
Sadly, as Jeffrey Dean Morgan himself would later explain, his filming schedule for the miniseries Texas Rising prevented him from returning to Shameless despite both productions trying to make it work. The Texas Rising miniseries features Bill Paxton and Ray Liotta, and it's a History Channel show based on the Texas Revolution against Mexico. Texas Rising only lasted for one season in 2015, whereas Shameless ran until its final season in 2021.
Fortunately for Jeffrey Dean Morgan, backing the wrong horse wasn't a huge career setback in this instance. Here's what Morgan said about the exit in an Instagram post (via Reddit):
Well… obviously was supposed to cast for a bit… but I was in Mexico shooting Texas Rising and we just couldn’t work out my schedule to get back and film. Both projects tried very hard. It was a bummer because I’m a big fan of Shameless and love that cast and John Wells. I get that it’s super weird me just showing up… with the seat neck tat and then disappearing. That wasn’t the plan.
When it was clear that scheduling conflicts meant Jeffrey Dean Morgan wouldn't return to Shamelesss, Charlie was written out and his arc assigned to new character Sean Pierce (Dermot Mulroney), who took over as Fiona's boss and love interest at Patsy's Pies. While it's a pity it didn't work out, Morgan's star would soon rise even further in 2016 thanks to The Walking Dead and his Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice cameo as Thomas Wayne. Either way, Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Shameless exit is odd when looking from the outside in, but it makes sense after the star's explanation.
Shameless Ending Explained: Frank's Death & What Happens To The Other Gallaghers
A decade of South Side chaos came to a close in the Shameless season 11 finale. Here's what happened to Frank Gallagher and his kids in the end.
What Was Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Shameless Story Going To Be?
It's Likely Charlie's Story In Shameless Would Have Mirrored Sean's
There's never been an official explanation given for what happened to Charlie Peters, and since the role wasn't recast, there's been speculation about where his arc could have gone. However, the writers clearly had huge plans for the Jeffrey Dean Morgan Shameless character, and many viewers have wondered what his narrative arc would have been.
It's likely that the role Sean ended up playing in Shameless would be more-or-less identical to Charlie's if Jeffrey Dean Morgan hadn't left the show. Sean's character was created to replace Charlie, after all, with many of the preplanned Shameless season 5 story elements for Morgan carrying over to Dermot Mulroney.
His role on Texas Rising might have faded away into obscurity, but it's clear in the long run that leaving Shameless inadvertently boosted Jeffrey Dean Morgan's career.
While it would have been interesting to see Jeffrey Dean Morgan play the role of Fiona's love interest on Shameless, his time on as Negan has created some of the most iconic moments in TV history. His role on Texas Rising might have faded away into obscurity, but it's clear in the long run that leaving Shameless inadvertently boosted Jeffrey Dean Morgan's career. For its part, Shameless was still phenomenal for another six seasons, so while it would have been interesting to see Jeffrey Dean Morgan have a larger role, it didn't need him by any stretch.
Shameless: 10 Best Guest Stars, Ranked
The guest stars of Shameless make fans get just as attached as the main cast and many are sad when these stars leave the show.
Would Charlie Have Been A Better Love Interest For Fiona?
Jeffrey Dean Morgan's Shameless Character Would Have Made For An Interesting Romance Arc
Given Jeffrey Dean Morgan's limited time on Shameless, it's difficult to assess whether Charlie would have been a better partner for Fiona compared to her other relationships. The show's essence lies in showcasing the rough edges of life, and Fiona's relationships are no exception. Fiona's love interests on Shameless were often complicated and flawed, reflecting the show's gritty and realistic take on relationships and personal struggles. Characters like Sean, Gus, and others all had their own issues that interacted with Fiona in different ways, for better or worse.
The two characters even visit a recovery meeting together, and Charlie had the potential to become a great life partner for Fiona in Shameless.
However, Charlie could have gone on to become a great partner of Fiona, as they're both flawed, complex, and have imperfections, but Charlie was extremely ive too. The two characters even visit a recovery meeting together, and Charlie had the potential to become a great life partner for Fiona in Shameless. Additionally, Morgan has tons of charisma, and his on-screen chemistry with Emmy Rossum was more exciting than Rossum with any other actor. However, it's also unlikely that any partner — including Jeffrey Dean Morgan as Charlie — would have been presented as a perfect match for Fiona.
Other Notable Cast Changes After Just One Episode
Jeffrey Dean Morgan’s character is unique because his appearance happens four seasons into the show. In most shows, when something happens to necessitate replacing an actor after just a single episode, it’s often the pilot episode instead. If an actor has to be recast in the middle of the show, it’s more likely that they’ve appeared in multiple episodes, as was the case for the many recastings in Game of Thrones. Some pilot episodes, however, end up having to go a vastly different route with a story because of the decision to get rid of a character.
Damon Wayans Jr. In New Girl
In New Girl, Daman Wayans Jr. plays Coach in the first episode of the series. The actor had appeared in the pilot while his other series, Happy Endings, was on the bubble. He thought the series would be canceled, and was looking for more work. When Happy Endings was picked up for one more season, however, Wayans had to exit the series because Happy Endings had the primary spot in his contract.
He wasn’t recast, but instead, Lamorne Morris was brought on to play Winston, another friend of the core group of characters. Wayans was also able to return to the series in season 3 for an extended run, so really, he got the best of both worlds.
Anne Dudek In Psych
Psych fans will know that in the first episode of the series, Juliet is not Lassiter’s partner. She makes her first appearance as a transfer to the department in the second episode. Anne Dudek played Lassiter’s partner in the pilot episode, but the reveal that she and Lassiter were having an affair didn’t test well with the audience that gave on the pilot, so they wrote the character out.
That ended up working out in the show’s favor as Juliet became Shawn’s long-term love interest in the series and Dudek ended up cast in Covert Affairs.
Lee Garlington In Seinfeld
A similar situation happened in Seinfeld. Lee Garlington appears in the pilot episode of the series as a waitress named Claire who works at the restaurant frequented by Jerry. She was intended to be a love interest for the character.
Claire, however, doesn’t appear after the pilot. As revealed in DVD commentary, the idea came to not use Claire in the rest of the series because she was from a different socioeconomic class than the rest of the characters and they didn’t feel she would fit in long term. Instead, Elaine is brought in as a main character in the second episode as Jerry’s ex, played by Julia Louis Dreyfuss.
Just like Jeffrey Dean Morgan leaving Shameless, these actors leaving their respective shows meant other actors stepped into new roles for the show.
Shameless
- Release Date
- 2011 - 2021-00-00
- Network
- Channel 4
- Showrunner
- John Wells
Cast
William H. MacyFrank Gallagher
Lip Gallagher
WHERE TO WATCH
Shameless is a Black Comedy, Family Drama created by Paul Abbott and starring William H. Macy, Emmy Rossum, and Justin Chatwin. The premise follows the Gallagher family and their closest friends as they deal with a not-so-helpful father, Frank Gallagher. His children each find their own path, growing into their own flawed people without much guidance or help from the family patriarch.
- Directors
- John Wells
- Writers
- Paul Abbott
- Seasons
- 11
Your comment has not been saved