Star Wars Threads
Have your say on the latest Star Wars topics in our Threads community.
latest
Would you like to see a Star Wars What If...? series?
I think the Star Wars galaxy could really benefit from a similar series like Marvel's What If...? There are so many scenarios fans would love to see explored: What if Qui-Gon survived to train Anakin? What if Ahsoka ed Maul at the end of the Clone Wars? What if Anakin defeated Obi-Wan on Mustafar? The possibilities are endless.
I was disappointed by THAT major Andor death because I wanted the character to live.
While I know he was part of the Empire, I have to say that I had grown quite fond of Syril over Andor's two seasons. Episode 8 is one of the show's best, and I loved how it showed Syril that his doubts were real. We see the man realize that everything he had done in his life for the Empire up to that point had been to help a nefarious organization. I wanted to see Syril's complex layers be explored beyond that reveal, but his tragic death came soon after that, and I think it squandered his remaining potential.
I watched Mon Mothma's secret Star Wars episode and her missing Andor season 2 scenes are perfect.
Before watching Andor, I only had a ing knowledge of the animated Star Wars: Rebels show. However, since I ed that Mon Mothma had appeared in the series, I looked up how it connected to the live-action series, finding season 3, episode 18, "Secret Cargo." Even though this is a more kid-friendly version of Star Wars, the animated episode explores the continuation of Mon Mothma's story from Andor, revealing how Grand iral Thrawn tried to catch her, how she was saved by the of the Ghost, and her hopeful speech to the galaxy. I loved all of it.
After Andor, what kind of grounded Star Wars story would you like to see next?
I really hope Lucasfilm finds a way to keep grounded stories going after Andor. One option could be a series about Bail Organa which aso feature Leia, or even Saw Gerrera's Partisans. The opportunity to explore the Star Wars galaxy with such a real lens has been fascinating. I certainly hope conversations for the future are happening behind-the-scenes.
What Star Wars Tales series do you want to see next after Underworld?
So far we've had Tales of the Jedi, Tales of the Empire, and now Tales of the Underworld. Brand-new stories have been told featuring Dooku, Ahsoka, Morgan Elsbeth, Barris Offee, Asajj Ventress, and Cad Bane. However, I'd love it if the next series was "Tales of the New Republic", providing unique stories animation could uniquely provide, like Princess Leia during the early days of the new democratic government, or even Luke training Ben Solo befor he fell to the dark side.
Is there a Star Wars collectible you've always wanted, but still don't have?
Star Wars Day is tomorrow, May the Fourth. That means there's going to be all kinds of different sales on collectibles, licensed products, and more. While I'm a big LEGO fan and have more than a few different models, I still don't have an AT-AT. I've been collecting for over 20 years, and somehow I don't have one of the most iconic Imperial vehicles (one day I will).
What did you think about Andor season 2 episodes 4-6?
Andor season 2 episodes 4-6 were just as impressive as the premiere episodes. Set a year closer to Rogue One and A New Hope in 3 BBY, it's fascinating to see how the revolution is picking up...as well as the Empire's oppression on Ghorman. I was floored by Saw Gerrera's conversation with Wilmon, and I Ioved seeing Mon Mothma go head to head with Director Krennic. I can't believe we're only halfway through season 2.
Pick a Star Wars character you think most deserves their own movie or show.
If Lucasfilm approached me and wanted me to pick just one Star Wars character to get their very own series or movie, it would have to be General Grievous. A proud Kaleesh warrior who was manipulated and duped by Count Dooku into becoming the leader of the Separatist Droid Army, I feel like Revenge of the Sith and even the canonical Clone Wars series only scratched the surface of Grievous' tragic story, and just how horrifying he can be.
Lucasfilm has the model, would you be into an animated Clone Wars style-Darth Vader series?
Darth Maul is getting his own animated series, and I do think animation is the best medium for his character, given how popular Sam Witwer's performance as Maul has become over the years. However, I think animation could also be how we finally get a Darth Vader series, perhaps one set in the Dark Time that echoes the iconic 2017 comic series. Lucasfilm has the model for a Clone Wars-style Vader thanks to the finale episode, so why not use it? There could also be key flashbacks to Anakin, allowing Matt Lanter to return.
After Andor, what Star Wars show are you most excited for?
We're about halfway through Andor season 2 with two more weeks to go. Tales of the Underworld is to drop in between on May the Fourth, Star Wars: Visions Vol. 3 is releasing later this year, and 2026 will see the release of Maul: Shadow Lord and Ahsoka Season 2. If I had to pick, I think I'm the most excited for Ahsoka season 2 (though Maul isn't far behind). It should be very cool to learn more about Maul's activities running Crimson Dawn during the Dark Times.
Do you think Rogue One is the best Star Wars movie (if so, why?)
Rogue One is always going to be in my top three favorite Star Wars movies. Connecting to both the prequels and original trilogy, Rogue One feels like a prime culmination of everything that Star Wars could and should be. Even if Darth Vader's iconic scenes weren't in the movie, Rogue One would still be one of my top favorites, and I'm so glad Andor exists as a show that is very much in the same wheelhouse and does the work of setting up the 2016 movie.
Did you like Saw Gerrerra's monologue with Wil in Andor Season 2?
Forest Whitaker's Saw Gerrera had an incredibly poignant moment in Andor season 2, episode 5, encouraging a young man to his Partisans while urging him to breathe in toxic fumes from volatile starfighter fuel. Sharing that "revolution is not for the sane" and that they themselves are the fuel of rebellion, it's a powerful yet very unhinged monologue that I found to be one of the best parts of the second season so far.
What did you think of Andor recasting Bail Organa?
Benjamin Bratt portrays the iconic Bail Organa in Andor season 2. The role has been made famous by Jimmy Smitts, but showrunner Tony Gilroy explained that even though they tried to get the actor to reprise the role, scheduling conflicts with another series he was in made it impossible. I thought Bratt did a great job of playing the character with the same mix of levity and gravitas that Smitts brought to the role. However, I still found it jarring to see the character portrayed by another person.
If Asajj Ventress were to ever get a live-action debut, who woud you cast?
Asajj Ventress has never made it beyond animation in the Star Wars galaxy, and she's only been referenced once in live-action by Anakin Skywalker in 2023's Ahsoka. If she were to one day make an appearance in live-action, I'd love to see someone like Charlize Theron bring the former Sith assassin to life, as I think she could do a great job capturing the character's likeness and complexities.
Do you think Andor will featue any Rebels characters and/or references?
As much as I'd love it, I don't think we'll be seeing any major Rebels characters appear in Andor season 2. However, it's worth noting that when Mon Mothma eventually flees Coruscant, it's the Ghost crew who gets her to safety to unify various Rebel cells together for the first time. I feel like a moment as big as that should at least get referenced. Conversely, I love to see a small cameo or reference to the ISB's Agent Kallus at some point.
What's your favorite quote from Revenge of the Sith?
I saw the 20th anniversary re-release of Revenge of the Sith this weekend, and it always blows my mind just hw many epic quotes are in the final prequel movie that have become iconic over the last two decades. You can't not love "This is where the fun begins" and "Hello There", but I'd be lying if I didnt' it that I have Anakin and Obi-Wan entire pre-duel Mustafar conversation memorized. "Only a Sith deals in absolutes".
What's your biggest hope for the Darth Maul animated series coming in 2026?
My biggest hope for Maul: Shadow Lord in 2026 is that we get some clear answers about Maul's thought processes during the Dark Times, specifically how he views his old master ruling the entire galaxy. I'm also really hoping for a canonical Darth Talon, which does seem likely considering the young Twi'lek girl who was heavily featured in the Star Wars Celebration footage.
What was your favorite moment in Andor season 2 episodes 1-3?
My favorite moment in Andor episodes 1-3 was definitely Andor stealing the TIE Avenger, though I also loved the Yavin 4 reveal at the end of episode 2. Likewise, the moment where Mon Mothma feels so helpless that all she can do is dance at the wedding was a tragically powerful moment, and I'm so glad her character is getting the spotlight she always deserved.
Which Star Wars video game character is your favorite?
There are some truly iconic Star Wars video game characters, and my favorite is a major tie between Starkiller from the Force Unleashed games and Cal Kestis from EA's Jedi games. Despite Starkiller now bein Legends, both existed during the Dark Times of the Empire's rule and their stories are absolutely iconic.
Do you agree with Samuel L. Jackson that Mace Windu survived Revenge of the Sith?
Samuel L. Jackson recently surprised audiences at a screening of the Revenge of the Sith 20th anniversary alongside Hayden Christensen. Reiterating once more that he believes Mace Windu survived his duel with Palpatine and his fall out of a window, I'd like nothing more than to believe him. A Mace Windu Jedi survivor story is just begging to be told, even if it ends with the powerful Jedi being taken down by Darth Vader and his Inquisitors.