The Vampire Diaries, there is still a dedicated fanbase that loves the bloodsuckers and everything that comes with them.
For fans that enjoyed every moment of First Kill, there are several supernatural-focused series appropriate for teen audiences are sure to be the next best watch. Whether fans want magic, vampires, or the hunters of such beings, there's a show out there for every viewer.
Legacies
In this next-generation series following The Vampire Diaries and The Originals, the story follows the students at the Salvatore School for the Young and Gifted in the town of Mystic Falls. In this school is a gifted hybrid, the only of her kind, Hope Mikaelson.
This show is entertaining for new fans as well as those that loved the series that made it a legacy. While there are many great scenes that keep this series entertaining, there are even some great filler episodes in Legacies. Fans of First Kill will appreciate the mix of the supernatural and teen drama.
The Vampire Diaries
In a town with a supernaturally charged history, Elena Gilbert meets and falls in love with a vampire, Stefan Salvatore. As the storyline progresses, things become increasingly complicated when Stefan's older brother Damon attempts to bring their ex-lover and the vampire that turned both of them, back.
Throughout the eight seasons, The Vampire Diaries has some wild storylines and intense plot twists. Those that enjoy this series will appreciate the focus on love in First Kill.
The Originals
In this first spinoff of The Vampire Diaries, the story follows Klaus Mikaelson and his three siblings as they try to take back control of the supernatural underground of New Orleans. Though similar to the original series, this series involves far more action and witchcraft.
Those that appreciate the vampire and vampire hunter quarrel in First Kill will find the werewolf-vampire hybrid Klaus as he faces off against vampires, witches, and werewolves. While a bit more intense than the other spinoff and original, this show has enough love and magic to keep a teen audience captivated.
Shadowhunters
In a surprise twist, Clary Fray suddenly finds herself in a world of human-angel hybrids who hunt demons in this exciting series. This series has all of the darkness, thrill, and forbidden love that comes with the perfect supernatural teen show.
Where First Kill has a lot of romance and action, Shadowhunters has this as well as fascinating magical elements. Those that have enjoyed the new Netflix Original series will take as much pleasure watching this action-packed teen fantasy series.
Teen Wolf
In this intense drama series, a young teenage boy looking for a purpose finds one in the most unexpected ways. When he's attacked by a wolf at night in the forest, he begins having strange experiences and senses, unlike anything humans are capable of.
Where First Kill is a coming-of-age series about a young vampire, this series is a coming-of-age of a young werewolf learning his place in his new life. Those that appreciate a good vampire story will also find pleasure watching this excellent werewolf story. Both use their supernatural premise to tell stories about universal themes connected to growing up, responsibility, and trust.
Buffy The Vampire Slayer
In this '90s hit, a young girl trying to have a normal life is leading a very dangerous and exciting double-like. Buffy Summers is a vibrant young girl in high school by day and a lethal, expert vampire hunter by night.
Though Buffy the Vampire Slayer is now over 25 years old, it still remains one of the most beloved supernatural teens shows to date. Those that like the forbidden romance in First Kill will devour this story about a merciless vampire hunter that falls for a not-so-bad vampire or two along the way.
Chilling Adventures Of Sabrina
This Netflix Original is based on the '90s hit Sabrina, The Teenage Witch. In this chilling adaption, a young girl has to live in the world of dangerous witchcraft while also yearning to hold onto her normal life and human friends.
Like First Kill, unpopular opinions about the Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, those looking for some teen angst and supernatural intensity will find the perfect mix in this series.
Fate: The Winx Saga
In this fantastical series, fairies attend a magical boarding school in another realm so they can learn how to use and conjure their magical abilities. The show focuses on Bloom, a fiery fairy with the elemental ability of fire.
While this show is more magic focused than that of vampires, it revolves around the complicated lives of young teenagers trying to find their place in a complex world. Fans of the world of First Kill will appreciate the magic-packed story of Fate: The Winx Saga.
Riverdale
Following the high school experience of Archie Andrews, Riverdale follows the lives of a group of teenagers as mysterious and otherworldly happenings take place in their small town.
While this series is considered one of the TV shows that only had one good season, it still continues to have a strong fanbase that hangs onto each season until the release of the next. Fans of chilling supernatural shows with a focus on young characters will appreciate this dramatic yet horrifying series.
Supernatural
In this supernatural series, two brothers go on chilling adventures as they hunt down monsters and demons of all natures, trying to rid the world of all matters of evil beings.
Though Supernatural focuses on mainly older adults, there is a strong fanbase of young audiences that enjoy the different supernatural beings and action in this series. Fans love all of the twists and turns involved in the storyline, keeping the audience entertained as the plot jumps from one obstacle to another more dire than the last.