For many people, the ‘Teen Titans’ cartoon from the early 2000s was their first introduction to DC lore beyond the basic of the Justice League. A solid mix of western and eastern animated styles, the show enjoyed clever writing, relatable characters, and one of the most iconic voice casts in the history of the medium. And one of the biggest jewels in the show’s crown was Starfire, the alien princess from the planet Tamaran who was still trying to get used to this whole ‘living on Earth’ thing, but was determined to protect her friends and maintained her sunny disposition in the face of a metric ton of adversity. Voiced by Hynden Walch, the character was a beacon of hope in a usually pretty dark show.

She always made an effort to be upbeat and was a key piece of the team. But there were a lot of things about her that were, for lack of a better word, odd. Some of her weird mannerisms and nonsensical traits can be attributed to her alien heritage and upbringing, but there were several instances when it was more a matter of the writers being liberal with their creative freedom than any semblance of internal logic. While they can never drown out the popularity and enjoyability of her character, it’s worth examining just a few things about Starfire that simply don’t make any sense whatsoever.

How Did She Get Her Costume?

The episode “Go!” in season 5 was a late-game origin story detailing how the five core of the team first assembled. In the narrative, Starfire first came to Earth after escaping her Gordanian captors but she is shown wearing a set of armor under a black version of her more well-known uniform at the time. By the end of the episode, she has changed into her usual purple two-piece with absolutely no explanation as to how she acquired it.

Why Didn't She Wear Her Crown?

In the episode “Betrothed” in season 3, it was revealed that the royal family of Tamaran is marked by a face-framing headgear, the same kind that Starfire’s sister Blackfire was seen wearing in her first appearance. Later, it’s shown that Starfire was wearing the same kind of crown when she came to Earth only to abandon it when she changed to her more traditional garb. But as a proud member of the Tamaranean race and of the royal family, why wouldn’t Starfire wear her crown more often.

Why Is Her Hair Neon In The Spin-Off?

While it is reviled by fans and is still considered a subpar spin-off of the original show, ‘Teen Titans Go!’ is still on the air and even got a feature-length film out of the deal. Though it made many, many changes to the original show, one of the only real physical changes was the color of Starfire’s hair, which was changed from a rich scarlet to an annoyingly bright pink. While the general color palate of ‘Go!’ was much brighter than the darker original, this color change really has no actual purpose.

Why Does Her Entire Society Wear The Same Clothes?

In “Betrothed,” viewers got their first look at Starfire’s Tamaranean society which she’d been talking up for the majority of the series. While the architecture and geology of the planet were suitably alien, one of the defining traits of her people were that they all seemed to wear the same combination of matching purple outfits. This is a pretty standard archetype of alien societies as it further demonstrates how different they are from humans, but it still doesn’t make sense.

How Did She Beat A Powered-Up Blackfire?

The rivalry between Starfire and her older sister Blackfire came to a close in their fight on Tamaran over the throne. During the battle, Blackfire’s alien powers were augmented by the Jewel of Charta which made her measurably more powerful than her sister. Nevertheless, Starfire prevailed in their battle through sheer force of will, as these things tend to go. But there’s no real explanation given as to how she was able to overpower Blackfire and therefore no reason why she should have won.

Why Is She So Naive For Her Age?

One of Starfire’s defining characteristics is her naivety. She generally is willing to believe the best in people and takes them at their word, even if it doesn’t make sense to her. While this has endeared her to fans of the show, it really doesn’t make sense when you learn that she’s far from a curious child. In fact, she’s over 150 years old. Granted that’s in Tamaranean years and it's likely their planet has a faster revolution period than Earth, but it’s still weird that she’s so unknowledgeable at her age.

Why Didn't She Have Some Of Her Powers From The Comics?

Starfire’s powers not only make her stand out among her teammates, but are pretty cool in their own right. Flight, invulnerability, and super strength are all par for the course for superheroes, but her laser vision and signature starbolts are unique to Tamaraneans in the show. But in the comic source material, she had a handful of other abilities that, for whatever reason, never made it onto the show. For example, she can control her body temperature to the point where she can melt steel with a touch. That never showed up in the cartoon.

Why Didn't She And Robin Get Together Sooner?

While it was hinted at for a good portion of the show’s run, Robin and Starfire only cemented their relationship in the TV-movie series finale. This makes sense seeing as Robin was such a tight-laced leader that he rarely let his emotions come into play. But Starfire was always an emotional being as he powers were directly tied to her feelings. If she was aware of how she felt about Robin, why didn’t she make a play sooner? They could have been dating for entire seasons before the show ended if she had.

How Did The Team Fall Apart Without Her?

The episode “How Long is Forever?” is perhaps the most heartbreaking of the show’s run. In it, Starfire is jettisoned years into the future. There, she discovers that without her presence, the Teen Titans fell apart and most went off to live sad, pathetic lives. But while Starfire is undoubtedly a valuable member of the team, it’s never explained how losing her led to the team’s disintegration. For example, how can she be blamed for Beast Boy going bald in his old age?

Why Are Her Powers Inconsistent?

Starfire and Raven’s power sets were explained to audiences early in the show during the episode “Switched,” wherein the two girls traded bodies ‘Freaky Friday’-style and had to adjust to each other’s abilities. Starfire explained that her powers come from her emotions, with a different positive emotion fueling a different power. But if that’s the case, how is she still able to fly when she’s too sad to feel “unbridled joy?” It appears that her powers aren’t so much tied to her feelings as they are to writers’ convenience.