With so many terrifying creatures and scary individuals always causing mayhem in Beacon Hills, it would have been easy to turn Teen Wolf into a horror film franchise. Every season, the residents of this town have to fight for their lives and defend their homes as these monstrous beings try to destroy life on earth.
While Scott McCall (Tyler Posey) and his friends usually come out victorious in these fights, mainly because their combined supernatural abilities make them one of the most powerful packs, that doesn't mean that they would be able to handle a villain in a one on one fight. If each character ended up facing someone that was as immortal as Halloween villain Jason Voorhees or as resilient as Michael Myers, chances are that not all of Scott's loved ones will make it out alive.
Least: Melissa McCall
Although she would prove to be extremely helpful if the number of casualties and injuries increased, Melissa McCall (Melissa Ponzio) would likely be one of the first people to die. As much as fans love her, this likable Teen Wolf character doesn't really have any skills that could help her if she found herself confronted by a serial killer.
During the show, it was always Scott, Isaac Lahey (Daniel Sharman), or Chris Argent (JR Bourne) that rushed to her aid when they discovered that she was in trouble. Since Melissa had no combat experience and was completely unaware of how to defend herself, she would probably receive a quick death.
Mason Hewitt
While Mason Hewitt (Khylin Rhambo) is certainly one of the most intelligent characters on the show, it's sad to say that his knowledge would only get him so far. It's likely that Mason's lack of supernatural abilities would be his downfall.
As one of the few human characters on the show, Mason doesn't have the regenerative abilities that Scott or his best friend, Liam Dunbar (Dylan Sprayberry). If he ended up getting wounded, then he would suffer from these injuries and be in a lot of pain. He would also tire himself out easily, which would make his odds of surviving very slim.
Stiles Stilinski
Although he may be one of the most likable characters on Teen Wolf, Stiles Stilinski (Dylan O'Brien) would sadly be another casualty. While many fans would agree that Stiles wouldn't just sit on the sidelines if his friends are in trouble, the best option for him here is to get out of Beacon Hills since his status as a human would make him a liability.
His hindrance is further proven by the fact that Stiles doesn't know how to properly defend himself since his main weapon of choice is his aluminum baseball bat. While it could stun the enemy for a little while, it's likely that Stiles would not be able to keep up with all the others and end up getting caught.
Allison Argent
While Allison Argent (Crystal Reed) died on Teen Wolf, she might just have lasted a bit longer than all her other friends if she confronted a serial killer. Considering that she came from a highly respected family of hunters and was quite skilled in weaponry and close combat, Allison would know how to set and lay traps.
Since her skills were mainly in long-range weapons, Allison would also have a good advantage in escaping if her plans went wrong. The only issue that may arise is Allison's irrationality and anger. If anything happened to one of her loved ones, Allison often became obsessed with her vengeance, which could lead to her making some reckless decisions that her opponent may end up capitalizing on.
Malia Tate
Although Malia Tate (Shelley Hennig) might have spent most of her childhood living in her werecoyote form, this experience may play to her advantage if she finds herself running for her life. During these years, Malia learned how to hunt, track, and fight, since this was essential for her survival. These were also skills that she carried with her when she was transformed back into her human self, spending most of her time defending her friends from some of Teen Wolf's dangerous hunters.
With many fans considering her to be one of the best fighters in Scott's pack, Malia could hold her own against a foe like Freddy Krueger. She knew how to counter attacks and would certainly use her knowledge of the Beacon Hills landscape to her advantage. Since Malia has proven to believe in self-preservation a few times, she would likely get out of a horror movie alive.
Braeden
She may have only made a few appearances, but Braeden (Megan Tandy) is one of the selfless and most underrated characters on the show. Braeden was a great ally for Scott's pack, having no qualms risking her own life to protect the young teens. She also proved to be an excellent markswoman and tracker, easily hunting down some of Teen Wolf's most powerful supernatural beings and collecting bounties on them.
All these attributes would help increase Braeden's odds of survival, as she was not one to go down without a fight. She would likely use all the weapons in her arsenal to help the residents of Beacon Hills defend themselves and would prove to be a great leader if the town decided they wanted to defeat the villains for good. Braeden could die this way, but with the odds in her favor, she would probably just end up escaping with her life.
Lydia Martin
While Lydia Martin (Holland Roden) may not be as skilled in combat as her other friends or have their regenerative abilities, that doesn't mean that people should underestimate her. If the of Scott's pack realized they were up against a slasher villain character, Lydia could prove to be their greatest asset, as her powers would end up saving their lives a lot.
Not only could she sense when one of her friends was in danger or about to die, but Lydia's Banshee screams also had the ability to either render a person unconscious or kill them. As long as the villain didn't get too close to her, Lydia could survive.
Scott McCall
When it comes to Scott McCall, many fans would like to believe that he would survive an encounter since he has a great number of survival skills thanks to his abilities as a werewolf. However, there might just be one downfall to his character: his morality.
Although Scott's morals are something that fans find quite irable, it might prove to be his greatest weakness if confronted by a heartless opponent. Scott's pure nature mainly comes down to the fact that he refuses to kill anybody, even those who had truly wronged him. Unfortunately, his refusal to kill might end up leading to his demise since that seems to be the only way to stop the majority of villains in horror movies.
Kira Yukimura
She may be kind and quiet, but Kira Yukimura (Arden Cho) was someone that fans wouldn't want to trifle with. Given her extensive powers as a Thunder Kitsune, which includes super speed, electrokinesis, healing abilities, and her great swordsmanship, Kira would have certainly had an epic showdown with someone like Michael Myers or Jason Voorhees.
She was an excellent combat fighter and could often disarm the enemy within a matter of seconds if they tried to attack her. She might actually be one of the few individuals who could get rid of these supernatural-like beings for good too since her kitsune has the ability to open portals to hell.
Most: Derek Hale
Derek Hale (Tyler Hoechlin) might not be the most powerful Alpha on Teen Wolf, but he certainly had the best chance of surviving a confrontation out of them all. Not only does he have an array of supernatural abilities, including super speed, super strength, and regenerative abilities, but Derek has also proven to be a great combat fighter and marksman.
While he certainly has his weaknesses, Derek is intelligent enough to know when it is best to attack and when it's best to hold off. He could certainly take down a slasher movie killer if given the chance.