The Traitors took the reality television world by storm when it premiered on Peacock. The show takes reality television personalities, along with everyday people, and puts them in a castle where the Faithful need to solve the mystery of whom the traitors are. The show piqued the interest of many fan bases because it included reality television stars.
Among these groups is the Big Brother fan base due to the show's inclusion of legends Rachel Reilly and Cody Calafiore. This got Big Brother fans pondering the question of, these other Big Brother contestants could be on The Traitors.
Danielle Reyes
Danielle Reyes was the runner-up of Big Brother 3 and is commonly regarded as one of the best players to never win. Her game was so good that it caused a rule change where the evicted houseguests were now sequestered and could not watch the show once voted off.
Danielle was a great strategist and read people well. So, if she was in the Faithful and not a traitor, she could do a great job of getting an idea of who is who. If she was a Traitor, she is so persuasive and such a good speaker she could convince the whole group she was with them, and then betray them at the end.
Dan Gheesling
Dan Gheesling was the winner of Big Brother 10 and runner-up of Big Brother 14. He is known as one of the three best players to ever play.
Dan was the best strategist on whatever season he is on, so he would implement a great game plan if he was on The Traitors. One of Dan's biggest strengths is taking the heat off of him if he is in the spotlight. If people were accusing him of being the traitor, odds are he would be able to get out of that stick situation whether he is a traitor or not.
Janelle Pierzina
Janelle Pierzina was on Big Brother 6,7,14 & 22, so she is an experienced player. She was very close to making it to the final two in her first two seasons, but could not quite get there.
Janelle might be known more for her physical game and all the records she set, but she understood the game well, which would help her on The Traitors. She is smarter than most people and her strategy in all of her Big Brother seasons was great. If she were a traitor on the show, she would excel at gaining people's trust and, therefore, coasting to the end.
Andy Herren
Andy Herren was the winner of the highly controversial Big Brother 15. He was quietly one of the sneakiest players all season and pulled off a great move to ensure his victory.
Andy would do fine as a member of the Faithful, but he would be entertaining as a traitor. When he convinced McCrae that he was not the one who voted Amanda out proved that he has what it takes to be coherent under pressure. So, if he is being investigated for being the traitor, he would give them no indication that he was it.
Helen Kim
Helen Kim was on Big Brother 15 and was voted out in 9th, due to her threatening strategic mind. She was arguably the smartest member of her cast as she always thought a few steps ahead.
Unlike other Big Brother castmates, Helen would be great as a member of the Faithful as she could interrogate someone and get information out of them. She did this on Big Brother 15 to people she was unsure about, like Howard. She would most likely do well as a traitor, but watching her become a sleuth to weave out the traitors would be very entertaining.
Will Kirby
Will Kirby was the winner of Big Brother 2 and came in 4th on Big Brother 7. Will's snarky confidence mixed with his great strategy made him one of the best and most entertaining players ever.
Will would be fun to watch on The Traitors if he is in the Faithful or a traitor, as just having him in reality television again would be great. His vivacious confidence would make him a high-profile cast member regardless of his role. Most Big Brother fans would probably want to see him work his way through the game as a traitor, however.
Vanessa Russo
Vanessa Russo was on Big Brother 17, and she was, by far, the best castmate on her season. She came in 3rd, but she would have won in a landslide if she made it to the final 2.
Ideally, Vanessa would be a perfect traitor. She was so persuasive during her Big Brother season that seeing her in a situation where she would need to take all the heat off of her would be very entertaining, from a strategic perspective. A large portion of the Big Brother community wants her to play again, so, perhaps, The Traitors could be her next stop.
Paulie Calafiore
Even though he is now better known for his time on The Challenge, Paulie Calafiore got his start on Big Brother 18. Paulie got off to a hot start but fizzled out quickly, as he was voted off in 8th place.
Paulie would be a good member of The Traitors for entertainment purposes only. He is a good enough strategist to get him on the show, but the chaos he would cause would make it a must-watch season. He would need to not go over the fine line of being too chaotic that he would be banished right off the bat. If he lasts a few days, however, he could stir up trouble.
Britney Haynes
Britney Haynes is one of the most well-liked contestants in Big Brother history. She came in 4th on Big Brother 12 and 8th on Big Brother 14.
Britney would be great on The Traitors because she would tell right away if someone is lying. She seemed to have her b*llsh*t detector on Big Brother, as she always could tell if someone was being straight up with her or not. Also, her diary room entries were most likely the best on the show, so she would just be incredibly entertaining with other reality television personalities.
Brett Robinson
Brett Robinson came in 6th on Big Brother 20. He is ed for his loud and arrogant personality and his famous argument with Rockstar.
Similarly to Paulie, Brett would be a good addition to The Traitors simply to cause chaos. He proved he was an able strategist on Big Brother 20, so it would not be a total shock if he made it on the show. And, all Big Brother fans know the chaos he can cause, so, even though some will probably root against him, it will increase the entertainment factor.