Summary

• Co-writer Jen D'Angelo expresses interest in a sequel to Totally Killer, citing potential for a thrilling continuation of the story.
• The ending of the horror-comedy left room for a follow-up, with open threads that could lead to new adventures for the characters.
• While viewership numbers have not been shared for the movie, Totally Killer's rave reviews could be a good sign of its chances at a sequel.

With nearly a year gone since the movie's release, co-writer Jen D'Angelo offers an intriguing response to a potential Totally Killer was a hit with critics on release, landing an 87% "Certified Fresh" approval rating from critics on Rotten Tomatoes.

During a recent interview with Screen Rant for her Emmy-nominated work on Quiz Lady, D'Angelo was asked about the possibility of a Totally Killer sequel. Though the co-writer acknowledged she has not had any official talks with director Nahnatchka Khan about a follow-up, she is keen to make one happen, as she would "work with her to the ends of the earth" and thinks there's "definitely ripe territory" for a sequel to happen. See what D'Angelo shared below:

Oh my gosh, I mean, there have not been talks, but I love Nahnatchka Khan, who directed Totally Killer. She's incredible, so I would work with her to the ends of the earth. So, if she wanted to do a sequel, I would be so thrilled to get in there. I mean, no spoilers — click away if you don't want a spoiler — but there is an extra time machine out there. We've got a lot of kids back in the '80s who were messed up inadvertently by it. There's definitely ripe territory for a sequel. But yeah, that was just such a fun world to play in, and collaborating with Sasha and David, the other two writers on it. I love that movie, it's so fun.

How Totally Killer 2 Could Happen

As D'Angelo notes, the Totally Killer ending did leave enough room for a potential sequel. Though Shipka's Jamie did successfully make it back to the present day and stop the Sweet 16 Killer in the past, this did also leave one of two time machines in the '80s for anybody to use should they discover it. While the Sweet 16 Killer was generally deemed a menace to Jamie's small town, it could also lead to someone being inspired to revive their legacy, be it in the past or present.

The other major thread left open from the Totally Killer ending for a sequel is the notebook Lauren put together for Jamie to inform her about the major changes to the present timeline after her journey to the past, one of which includes Chris. At the start of the film, he was a podcaster covering the Sweet 16 Killer's legacy in the town, though was later revealed to be a second masked killer looking to restart his killing spree to create new content. During his trip to the past, Chris also murdered his own father in front of the younger version of himself.

The notebook shown in Totally Killer ending reveals that the new-present-day version of Chris has traveled to an Indian monastery to become a monk after being traumatized by the sight of his older self killing his dad, with Lauren keeping tabs on him "just in case". Though this could be a point of reverse character development, the sequel could certainly find him returning to Vernon to use the time machine to undo the events of the first movie, including his father's death, which could also see the revival of one or more Sweet 16 Killers.