Netflix viewers are obsessed with Madlyn Ballatori and Colby Kissinger's reunion reveal was by far the most shocking. Since the social experiment dropped on April 8, fans have watched six couples decide whether they should stay together and get married or end their relationships for good. With the original couples separating and living with other contestants for three weeks, before finishing out the remaining three weeks back together, the series is filled to the brim with tears and drama.
While two couples (Alexis Maloney and Hunter Parr and Lauren Pounds and Nathan Ruggles) left the show early after quickly getting engaged, fans were convinced that Madlyn and Colby would break up before (or on) Ultimatum Day. Although Colby wanted to marry Madlyn, and made it clear that he was not interested in seriously dating any of his female co-stars, Madlyn was hesitant to accept a proposal and commit to one person for life.
After Madlyn spent time with Randall Grffin (Shanique Imari's then-boyfriend) and Colby got to know April Marie (Jake Cunningham's then-girlfriend), the two got back together, and almost immediately began fighting. Before the finale and reunion episodes dropped on April 13, viewers watching The Ultimatum thought that there was no way that Colby's marriage ultimatum to Madlyn would be successful.
Madlyn Ballatori & Colby Kissinger Shocked Viewers
When Ultimatum Day came around, Madlyn and Colby shocked fans. Not only did Madlyn accept Colby's proposal, but the two then got married on the spot. If that wasn't surprising enough, Madlyn and Colby revealed an even bigger surprise when they walked out for the show's reunion. That's because Madlyn is pregnant with their first child and due in just weeks. While how Madlyn talked to (and about) Colby throughout the social experiment.
Some Fans Think Madlyn Ballatori Is A Hypocrite
Many people think that Madlyn's attitude about Colby talking to other women was hypocritical. For example, Madlyn stated multiple times that she wanted to be intimate with Randall. While appearing to be under the influence of alcohol, Madlyn was not afraid to speak her mind. She let her feelings be known, which led to several instances of name-calling and yelling, all directed at Colby. However, this behavior even extended to their co-stars, with Madlyn telling April at one point during the switch, "I want to hate you but I can't."
Certain Viewers Doubt Colby Kissinger's Nice Guy Persona
While Madlyn has caught heat from those tuning into The Ultimatum, social media s have also cast doubt on Colby, making their marriage and pregnancy even more surprising. As the one who gave the ultimatum, viewers originally had sympathy for the Texas cowboy, and thought that Colby deserved better than Madlyn. As episodes continued, however, online discussions began shifting, and some viewers began finding Colby manipulative and narcissistic.
Several The Ultimatum instances have led some people to believe that Colby was not only aware of the cameras, but created a likeable persona to get a better edit. Not only did Colby tell Madlyn that he partook in the show "for her" during episode 8 (a clear moment of deflection to viewers) but many were turned off by his declaration that he would "help Lauren," with her decision not to have children during their first full conversation.
As the only original couple expecting a child, fans of The Ultimatum: Marry Or Move On are more interested in Madlyn and Colby's relationship than ever. With their baby girl arriving soon, it can be said that Colby's ultimatum was a success despite the duo's chaotic ride on the show. Not only are viewers waiting to see a glimpse of their child, but they're also awaiting news of a potential season 2.
Sources: r/TheUltimatumNetflix/Reddit